Dublin City Council · 4170/23
13 Brabazon Square, Dublin 8
Approved in Sept 2023.
- 18 Jul 2023Received
- 11 Sept 2023Approved
- 20 Oct 2023Final approval
- Status
- Approved
- Decision
- Approved retention permissio · 11 Sept 2023
- Council
- Dublin City Council
- Type
- Retention Permission
- Site
- 38 m²
What’s proposed
RETENTION: Retention planning permission for single storey extension to rear of existing house with ancillary works
Planning details
- Reference
- 4170/23
- Local authority
- Dublin City Council
- Status
- Granted · register status “Decision Notice Issued”
- Received
- 18 Jul 2023
- Decision due
- 11 Sept 2023 · decided 11 Sept 2023
- Decision
- Grant retention permissio on 11 Sept 2023
- Site area
- 38 m² from the mapped boundary, not the council's figure
Nearby 28 · 500 m · 12 months
Distance
Time
- WithdrawnESB Telecoms Ltd Telecommunications Compound, ESB's Marrowbone Lane 38kV Substation, Marrowbone Lane, Dublin 8
- Open27-29 New Row South, Dublin 8. The application site is located at the junction of New Row South to the northwest Blackpitts to the west and Fumbally Lane to the south and southeast
- Awaiting decisionUnit 3, Southgate, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Awaiting decision42-46, Thomas Street, Dublin 8 D08 AW86
- Awaiting decisionUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8, D08 A5XK
- Withdrawn42-46 Thomas Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8,
- Withdrawn59 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08 FY04
Show all 28
- Granted27-29 New Row South, Dublin 8. The application site is located at the junction of New Row South to the northwest,, Blackpitts to the west and Fumbally Lane to the south and southeast. The site contains a Protected Structure, (referred to as a former laun
- Awaiting decision1-2 Chamber Street, at the junction with Ardee Street and Chamber Street, Dublin 8, D08 H3K5
- Withdrawn1-2 Chamber Street, at the junction with Ardee Street and Chamber Street, Dublin 8, D08 H3K5
- Awaiting decisionThe Maltings Business Park, 54/55 Marrowbone Lane, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnThe Maltings Business Park , 54/55 Marrowbone Lane,, Dublin 8.
- Granted103, The Coombe, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn103, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 R9F3
- Withdrawn103, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 R9F3
- Granted28, O'Curry Road, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedSite at Thomas Street, including No. 144 Thomas Street (the site is bounded by No. 143 Thomas Street, and Marshalsea Lane to the east and No's 151-156 Thomas Street to the west), Dublin 8
- GrantedSite bounded by numbers 11 & no. 32 Hanover Lane, Dublin 8
- Granted161 - 163 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnSite bounded by numbers 11 & no. 32 Hanover Lane, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnContainer Coffee, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn161 - 163 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, Dublin, D08FF6A
- Refused7 Brabazon Square, Dublin 8, D08A2R5
- WithdrawnGuinness Storehouse, Market Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn161-163 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Granted28-29 Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 08
- GrantedSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street (known as the Liberties House), Dublin 8, D08 RH5K
- WithdrawnSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street (known as the Liberties House), Dublin 8, D08 RH5K
- WithdrawnCapello, 54A Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 PV25
- CommencedPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount, Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedNos. 28-34 Braithwaite Street & Nos. 63-66 Pimlico, Dublin 8, (bounded by No. 35 Braithwaite Street to the east & north, Nos. 61 & 62 Pimlico to the north, Braithwaite Street/Poole Street Playground to the west, & by St. Margaret’s Avenue & St. John's Ave
- GrantedDublin Simon Community, 12-14 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8, D08 KX89
- WithdrawnFormer Parish Centre, 12-14, Carman's Hall, Dublin 8, D08 KX89
- Withdrawn28-34 Braithwaite Street & 63-66 Pimlico, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn134 Thomas Street West, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn134 Thomas Street West, Dublin 8, D08 T6H9
- Withdrawn28-34 Braithwaite Street & 63-66 Pimlico, Dublin 8
- Granted76 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 KD6C
- Commenced33, Saint Thomas Road, Dublin 8
- Granted7 Brabazon Square, Dublin 8, D08 A2R5
- Granted109, Thomas Street, Usher's Quay, Dublin 8
- GrantedBru Chaoimhin, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn7 Brabazon Square, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn109, Thomas Street, USher's Quay, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnBru Chaoimhin, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided42 Marrowbone Lane, Dublin 8, D08 FY6W
- Withdrawn42 Marrowbone Lane, Dublin 8, D08 FY6W
- WithdrawnBru Chaoimhin, Cork St., The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted67-70 Meath Street, Dublin 8, D08 YCK4
- RefusedRainsford Avenue, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- Granted12, Hanover Street West, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnBru Chaomhin, Cork St, The Liberties, Dublin 8.
- GrantedUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- RefusedApartment 51 La Rochelle, High Street,, Dublin 8, Ireland,, D08FW93
- Commenced134, Thomas Street West, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnUnit 3, Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn109 Thomas Street, NCAD Campus, Usher's Quay, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn134 Thomas Street West, Dublin 8, D08 T6H9
- GrantedSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St,, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedCentra, 50 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnApartment 51, High Street, La Rochelle, Dublin 8, Ireland, D08 FW93
- Granted81, The Coombe, The Liberties , Dublin 8
- Withdrawn81, The Coombe, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 YR66
- GrantedApt. 1, 4 Ardee Street, Dublin 8, D08 PA61
- Withdrawn81, The Coombe, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- RefusedThe Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St,, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced1-3 Thomas Court, Dublin 8; at the rear of 10-13 Thomas Street West, Dublin 8 with vehicular access, to Rainsford Street to the south;a vacant site between 13 &17 Thomas Street West, Dublin 8; and a, surface car park to the rear of 17 to 25 Thomas Street
- Granted17, Hanover Street West, Dublin, Dublin 8
- RefusedGround Floor Unit, La Rochelle, High Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnGround Floor Unit, La Rochelle, High Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 YW72
- Appeal decidedRear of 115-117 The Coombe, to the rear of BIMM Music Institute, Dublin 8, D08 A970
- Appeal decidedNo. 8 Newmarket and No. 18 Mill Street, Dublin 8
- CommencedFrom Here Student Living, 35 - 38 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided128 Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08K5RH
- Granted58-59, Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn58/59, Meath St, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 F8K0
- Granted79 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Granted79 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn79, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn79 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, on corner with Francis Street.
- Granted37 Thomas Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- GrantedRumi Cafe Bar, 28 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08 PF61
- GrantedCunningham House, 130 Francis Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedSite at Thomas Street, including No. 144 Thomas Street (the site is bounded by No. 143 Thomas Street, and Marshalsea Lane to the east and No's 151-156 Thomas Street to the west), Dublin 8
- Commenced1 Mill Street , The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted8 Meath Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn1, Mill Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Commenced58-59, Meath Street, Dublin 8
- CommencedCentra, 50, Thomas Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 E89T
- Commenced24, Ash Street, Dublin 8, D08 XC6P
- Withdrawn37 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn24, Ash Street, Dublin 8, D08 XC6P
- Commenced7 O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8, D08 R8Y7
- CommencedStaycity Aparthotel, 135 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08 P5N2
- Granted42-76 Saint Augustine Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedA 0.1401 Ha Site on Lands at Molyneux Yard and Engine Alley and the site to the rear of No. 83 Meath Street, Dublin 8, (the site includes No. 75 Molyneux Yard)
- GrantedLands at the corner of Oliver Bond Street, and St. Augustine Street (Mullinahack), Christchurch, Dublin 8
- Refused83 Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted59 Francis Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedSite bound by Vicar Street to the east and Molyneux Yard to the west, the site adjoins public space to the south that fronts onto Swift's Alley further to the South, Dublin 8
- GrantedHeyday, 16-22 Carman's Hall Student Accommodation, Garden Lane, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Culvert Apartments, 7 Pim Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn59, Francis Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8 , D08 FY04
- WithdrawnThe Culvert Apartments, 7 Pim Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- GrantedGround Floor Unit 1, Staycity Aparthotel, 135 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08P5N2
- GrantedGround Floor Unit 2, Staycity Aparthotel, 135 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08P5N2
- Commenced6, Power's Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn6, Power's Square, Dublin 8
- Commenced2-3 Mark's Alley West, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Brickworks, Brickfield Lane, Dublin 8. The site is located to the west of Brickfield Lane and, north of Brown Street South
- Granted76 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 KD6C
- WithdrawnSite bound by Vicar Street to the east and Molyneux Yard to the west, the site adjoins public space that fronts onto Swift's Alley further to the South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn2-3, Marks Alley West, Dublin 8
- Granted72, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- RefusedRumi Cafe Bar , 28 Francis Street, Dublin 8 , D08PF61
- Granted1, Meath Terrace, Meath Place, Dublin 8, D08 VEW5
- Granted8, Spitalfields, The Coombe , Dublin 8
- WithdrawnNo. 72 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Granted83 Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted10-13 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnNo. 72 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Granted15, Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08RX48
- Withdrawn10-13 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 PX8H
- Withdrawn83, Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted113, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Refused13, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedSite bounded by no's. 11 & 32 Hanover Lane, Dublin 8
- GrantedAt the junction of Earl Street South and the lane identified as Meath Market Dubin 8, (also denoted St. Thomas Abbey) Dublin 8
- GrantedApt. 1, 4 Ardee Street, Dublin 8, D08PA61
- Withdrawn15, Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08RX48
- GrantedOn the public footpath on the southern side of Cork Street, outside "The Loom" and opposite 113 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced20, Ash Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8 D08 YH2A
- Commenced32, Brown Street South, The Tenters,Dublin 8 D08 X8A0
- Appeal decided2-3 Mark's Alley West, Dublin 8
- Commenced27, The Coombe, Dublin 8
- Commenced18-19, Francis Street, The Liberties, Dublin, D08 EK06
- Commenced13, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 YC9V
- Granted10, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 W1X0
- GrantedTaylor's Lane, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 YP0E
- GrantedSite bound by Vicar Street to the east and Molyneux Yard to the west, the site adjoins public space to the south that fronts onto Swift's Alley further to the South, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided58-59, Meath Street and part of 27 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8
- Refused5, Ardee Street, Dublin 08
- WithdrawnVicar Street, Swift Alley, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnTaylor's Lane, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 YPOE
- CommencedNewmarket Square, Dublin 8, P08 P3Y2. The overall site is bound by St. Luke's Avenue, Newmarket Square, Brabazon Street & Newmarket
- Commenced45, Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn5 Ardee Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided76, Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 KD6C
- Granted129, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- RefusedRear of 36-37 Earl Street South, Dublin 8, D08 XY6P
- WithdrawnSite bound by Newmarket Square to the north, Ardee Street to the west and Mill Street to the south (including City House and Unit 3, Newmarket, Dublin 8), Newmarket, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn129, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided92-93, Francis Street and 1-3 Mark's Alley West, Dublin 8
- Granted27, John Dillon Street, Christchurch, Dublin 8 D08 K5K6, with Davis Place to the rear
- Commenced54 John Street South, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 N7CO
- Withdrawn27, John Dillon Street, Christchurch, Dublin 8 D08 K5K6
- Withdrawn27, John Dillon Street, Christchurch, Dublin 8 D08 K5K6
- GrantedOn the footpath on the southern side of Cork Street outside The Loom and opposite 113 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn92-93, Francis Street and 1-3 Mark's Alley West, Dublin 8
- GrantedCorner site (known as Lawlor's Corner), at the junction of Summer Street South and Marrowbone Lane encompassing 72 Marrowbone Lane and 3 Summer Street South, Dublin 8, D08 XV2K
- Granted27, The Coombe, Dublin 8 D08 CR2C
- CommencedNos. 9, 10, Ardee Street corner St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8, D08KP9P
- WithdrawnCorner site (known as Lawlor’s Corner), at the junction of Summer Street South and Marrowbone Lane encompassing 72 Marrowbone Lane, 3 Summer Street South, Dublin 8, D08 XV2K
- GrantedOn the public footpath on the Northern side of Dean Street near the junction with Patrick Street outside 'Ovenden House', Dublin 8
- Withdrawn15 Meath Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 RX48
- Commenced26, 26A & 27, Meath Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedUnit 3, Southgate, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Granted6, Weaver's Square, Dublin 8 D08 RHH4
- Withdrawn6, Weaver's Square, Dublin 8
- RefusedSite bounded by numbers 11 & no. 32, Hanover Lane, Dublin 8
- Refused22, Reginald Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- GrantedArthurs House, 1 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 AX97
- WithdrawnSite bounded by numbers 11 & no. 32 Hanover Lane, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnArthurs House, 1 Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 AX97
- Granted58-59 Meath Street and part of 27 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8
- Granted33, Mill Street, Liberties, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Ground Floor Commercial Unit, 98-99 Francis Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced16, John Street South, Dublin 8 D08 F2V5
- Granted12, Thirlestane Terrace, Thomas Court, Dublin 8
- CommencedPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount , Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn16, John Street South, Dublin 8
- Commenced27-29, New Row South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn33, Mill Street, Liberties, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount, Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- Granted4, Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- CommencedLands at Guinness Brewery to the South of James Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedAparto the Loom, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn12, Thirlestance Terrace, Thomas Court, Dublin 8
- Commenced13-17, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided76 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Refused135-143 Francis Street, Dublin 8, D08 P5N2
- WithdrawnAparto The Loom, Cork Street, the Liberties, Dublin 8
- GrantedSite of 0.115 hectares located at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8 (lands comprising part of the site known as the IDA Ireland Small Business Centre at Newmarket Industrial Estate and Brabazon Place and including pa
- CommencedNewport Street Apartments, 17-19 Newport Street, (at the corner of Newport Street and Pim Street), Dublin 8
- Withdrawn12 Thirlestane Terrace, Thomas Court, Dublin 8, D08 X3X6
- WithdrawnSite at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8 (lands comprising part of the site known as the IDA Ireland Small Business Centre at Newmarket Industrial Estate and including parts of 10, 12, 13 and 14 Newmarket Industrial)
- GrantedESB's Francis Street 110kV Electricity Substation, Francis Street/Swift's Alley/Garden Lane, Dublin 8.
- GrantedSite of former No. 2 Brewery, which incorporates the Brew Hall Building and connected Front Wing Building, and which is part of the existing Guinness Brewery lands to the South of James's Street, Dublin 8
- CommencedSite known as The Brewery Block bounded, By, Ardee Street, Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row, Saint Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn76 Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced91-93, Meath Street, Dublin 8, D08 YN15
- WithdrawnESB's Francis Street 110kV Substation, Francis Street, Swift's Alley, Dublin 8
- CommencedSweeney's Terrace, Dublin 8, including No.4 Sweeney's Terrace (a habitable house to the rear of No. 1 Sweeney's Terrace)., The site is generally bound by a Student Accommodation and Residential Scheme permitted under An, Bord Pleanala Ref. ABP-303436-19
- WithdrawnSite at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn91-93, Meath Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnHeyday, 16-22 Carman's Hall Student Accommodation, Garden Lane, Dublin 8
- GrantedUnit 2, 18-20 Mark's Alley West, Frances St., Dublin 8
- Granted18, John Street South, Dublin 8, D08 VXR9.
- Granted17, Meath Place, The Coombe, Dublin 8
- Commenced23, Reginald Street, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 K024
- GrantedAugustinian Priory, also known as St John's Priory, Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 F8NW, at the corner of John's Lane West and Thomas Street
- Withdrawn17, Meath Place, The Coombe, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn23, Reginald Street, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 K024
- Appeal decided37, Oscar Square, Saint Catherine's Dublin 8
- WithdrawnAugustinian Priory, also known as St. John's Priory, Thomas Street, Dublin 8, D08 F8NW
- Granted58/59 Meath Street, Dublin 8 & part of 27 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn58-59, Meath Street and 27 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedNo. 8 Newmarket and No. 18 Mill Street, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Loom, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn18, John Street South Dublin, D08 VXR9
- Withdrawn58-59, Meath Street, Part 27 Carman's Hall , Dublin 8
- Withdrawn58-59, Meath Street and part of 27 Carman's Hall, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnUnit 2, 18-20, Marks Alley West, Off Francis Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn8, Newmarket, and 18, Mill Street, Dublin 8 (bounded by Mill Street to the south, Mill Lane to the east and Newmarket to the north).
- Withdrawn17, Meath Place, The Coombe, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided118, Thomas Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnGround Floor Retail Unit, The Loom, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn118 Thomas Street, Dublin 8,
- Granted60 The Coombe, Dublin 8
Homes nearby
- For sale31 Reginald Street, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 W9W4
- For sale67 The Coombe, South Dublin City, Dublin 8, D08 E8K1
- For sale70 The Coombe, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 W2K2
- For sale19 Ardee Court, Adree Street, Dublin 8, D08 YC42
- For saleApartment 13, 27, Tramyard Exchange, Carman's Hall, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 K15X
- For sale18 Summer Street South, The Coombe, Dublin 8, D08 E2PK
Development land nearby
- Permitted, not started · 49 homes granted 02 Jun 2026, expires 02 Jun 2031 — 28-34 Braithwaite Street and 63-66 Pimlico (0.1 km)
- Permitted, not started · 11 homes granted 01 Dec 2025, expires 01 Dec 2030 — 67-70 Meath Street (0.1 km)
- Permitted, not started · 40 homes granted 14 Jul 2023, expires 14 Jul 2028 — Lawlor's Corner (0.2 km)
- Residential land off Meath Place, Dublin 8 (0.0 km)
- Residential land off Gray Square, Meath Street, Dublin 8 (0.1 km)
Zoning
Zone Z2 - DEV PLAN 2022-2028
R2 — Existing residential
An established residential area. The objective is to protect existing residential amenity as well as to provide housing — which is the objective a neighbour's objection to an overbearing extension is usually argued under.
Protections nearby 250 m
Flood area nearby (OPW maps). floodinfo.ie ↗
- EPA-licensed facility · 3
- NIAH-recorded building · 17
- Recorded monument · 31
Where this comes from
National planning feed (NPAD), fetched 11 Sept 2026, 18:51.
Source: National Planning Application Database · fetched 11 Sept 2026, 18:51
| Source | Licence | Fetched | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| National Planning Application Database | CC BY 4.0 | 11 Sept 2026, 18:51 | open |
Summary
4170/23 is a planning application to Dublin City Council for RETENTION: Retention planning permission for single storey extension to rear of existing, received on 18 Jul 2023; permission was granted on 11 Sept 2023.