Dublin City Council · WEB1439/24
6 Saint Thomas Road, Dublin 8
Approved in Jul 2024. Building started in 2024.
- 15 Apr 2024Received
- 7 Jun 2024Approved
- 27 Jun 2024Appealed
- 27 Jun 2024Appeal: Invalid
- 19 Jul 2024Final approval
- 12 Aug 2024Building started
- Status
- Building startedi
- Decision
- Approved · 7 Jun 2024
- Council
- Dublin City Council
- Type
- Permission
- Site
- 87 m²
- Appeal
- ACP 320026 · Invalid
What’s proposed
The development will consist of conversion of existing roof/attic storage space to non-habitable space with dormer window to the rear, new Velux window to the front elevation with attached single storey flat roof extension to rear yard and all associated works
Planning details
- Reference
- WEB1439/24
- Local authority
- Dublin City Council
- Status
- Commenced · register status “Decision Notice Issued”
- Received
- 15 Apr 2024
- Decision due
- 7 Jun 2024 · decided 7 Jun 2024
- Decision
- Grant permission on 7 Jun 2024
- Site area
- 87 m² from the mapped boundary, not the council's figure
Nearby 42 · 500 m · 12 months
Distance
Time
- Open27-29 New Row South, Dublin 8. The application site is located at the junction of New Row South to the northwest Blackpitts to the west and Fumbally Lane to the south and southeast
- Awaiting decisionUnit 3, Southgate, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Awaiting decision11, Saint John's Street, Dublin 8
- Awaiting decisionUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8, D08 A5XK
- Granted53, Raymond Street, Dublin 8, D08H7F4
- Awaiting decision13, Harty Place, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 KW3F
- Granted19, Harty Place, Dublin 8, D08 R2Y2
Show all 42
- Granted38, Donore Avenue, Dolphin's Barn, Dublin 8, D08 T2D0
- Withdrawn53 Raymond Street, Dublin 8, Dublin, D08 H7F4
- Withdrawn13, Harty Place, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn11 Saint John's Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced24 Daniel Street, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 E4P1
- Withdrawn24, Daniel Street, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 E4P1
- Withdrawn11, Saint John's Street, Dublin 8
- Awaiting decision4 Sandford Park, S Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 X4V8
- Awaiting decision3, Sandford Gardens, Dublin 8, D08R3K0
- Awaiting decision57, Upper Clanbrassil Street, Dublin 8, D08Y9P4
- Awaiting decision1 Old Mill Court, Malpas street, Dublin 8, D08P3C8
- Withdrawn1 Old Mill Court, Malpas Street, Dublin 8, D08P3C8
- Granted27-29 New Row South, Dublin 8. The application site is located at the junction of New Row South to the northwest,, Blackpitts to the west and Fumbally Lane to the south and southeast. The site contains a Protected Structure, (referred to as a former laun
- Awaiting decision1-2 Chamber Street, at the junction with Ardee Street and Chamber Street, Dublin 8, D08 H3K5
- Withdrawn1-2 Chamber Street, at the junction with Ardee Street and Chamber Street, Dublin 8, D08 H3K5
- Awaiting decision47, St Albans Road, Dublin 8
- Awaiting decision69D Donore Avenue, Dublin 8. The site is situated to the south and west of White Swan Business Centre, to the south east of properties on Elford
- RefusedSite to rear of No.'s 16 & 17 Susan Terrace, Inchicore, Dublin 8, D08 W622
- Refused57, Upper Clanbrassil Street, Dublin 8, D08Y9P4
- WithdrawnFumbally Square and Fumbally Court, Fumbally Lane, Dublin 8
- Granted28, O'Curry Road, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn57, Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8
- Granted4 Sandford Avenue, Dublin 8
- Granted8, Susan Terrace, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn8, Susan Terrace, Dublin 8
- Granted39, Saint Thomas Road, Dublin 8, D08 X8P6
- Awaiting decisionGriffith College, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- Granted10 Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8, D08R6KK
- WithdrawnGriffith College, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn10, Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8, D08 R6KK
- Granted3 Sandford Avenue, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08T4A6
- Commenced6 Sandford Gardens, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn3 Sandford Avenue, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn6, Sandford Gardens, Dublin 8, D08 A2N3
- GrantedSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street (known as the Liberties House), Dublin 8, D08 RH5K
- WithdrawnSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street (known as the Liberties House), Dublin 8, D08 RH5K
- GrantedLands to the rear of 26 Raymond Street, Dublin 8
- Granted23 Saint Albans Road, Dublin 8
- CommencedSite at the former Player Wills site , South Circular Road , St. Catherines's Avenue and Donore Avenue , Dublin 8
- CommencedPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount, Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnSite at the former Player Wills site , South Circular Road , St. Catherines's Avenue and Donore Avenue , Dublin 8
- Commenced2, Hamilton Street, Saint Catherine's, Dublin 8
- Commenced33, Saint Thomas Road, Dublin 8
- Granted62, Lombard Street West, Dublin 8
- GrantedBru Chaoimhin, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnBru Chaoimhin, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Commenced42, Greenville Terrace, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnBru Chaoimhin, Cork St., The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnBru Chaomhin, Cork St, The Liberties, Dublin 8.
- Granted15, Wolseley Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedUnit 3 Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn5 Lauderdale Terrace, New Row South, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnUnit 3, Newmarket Yards, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Commenced8, Emorville Avenue, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- GrantedSite at the Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St,, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street, Dublin 8
- Granted37, Lombard Street West, Portobello, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn8 Emorville Avenue, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn37, Lombard Street West, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08Y8W6
- Granted13, Williams Place South, Portobello, Dublin 8 DO8 V2X8
- Granted9, Saint Catherine's Avenue, Dublin 8, D08 K6DO
- Commenced13, Saint Michael's Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 H3K2
- Withdrawn9 Saint Catherines Avenue, Dublin 8, D08K6D0
- Commenced14, O'Donovan Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 H9N6
- Granted9, Ingram Road, Dublin 8, D08 A5N7
- Commenced39 St Thomas Road, Dublin 8, Dublin 8, D08 X8P6
- Withdrawn39, Saint Thomas Road, Dublin 8
- GrantedUnit 6, Cathedral Court, New Street South, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Granted12, Blackpitts, Dublin 8
- Commenced18 Merton Avenue,, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08AH60
- GrantedCathedral Court, New Street South, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn12, Blackpitts, Dublin 8
- Granted81, The Coombe, The Liberties , Dublin 8
- Withdrawn81, The Coombe, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 YR66
- GrantedApt. 1, 4 Ardee Street, Dublin 8, D08 PA61
- Withdrawn81, The Coombe, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Commenced17, Harty Place, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 R5W8
- RefusedThe Old Glass Factory, rear of Nos. 113-115 Cork Street, 118 Cork St,, and lands rear of 119-122 Cork Street, & 56 John Street, Dublin 8
- Granted13, Williams Place South, Portobello, Dublin 08
- Withdrawn13, Williams Place South, Dublin 8
- Refused26, Harman Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced15, Wolseley Street, Dublin 8, D08 R2DR
- Appeal decidedRear of 115-117 The Coombe, to the rear of BIMM Music Institute, Dublin 8, D08 A970
- Commenced23, Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8 , D08YY2W
- Appeal decided12, Eugene Street, Dublin 8 D08 C6T2
- Granted50, Harty Place, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedThe Headline Bar, 57 Clanbrassil Street Lower and South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 HC79
- Appeal decidedNo. 8 Newmarket and No. 18 Mill Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided28, Daniel Street, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 X7DD
- CommencedFrom Here Student Living, 35 - 38 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced11, Ingram Road, Dublin 8, D08 V9R3
- Withdrawn28, Daniel Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided128 Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08K5RH
- Commenced59, Harty Place, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn59, Harty Place, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 R8Y0
- Granted10, Arbutus Place, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 Y3OC
- Commenced23 O'Donovan Road, Dublin 8, D08 H2RO
- Granted21 Merton Avenue, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 Y1FC
- Appeal decided35 Darleys Terrace, St. Catherines, Dublin 8
- Commenced1 Mill Street , The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn1, Mill Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe City Lodge Building Rear Annex, The Old Meath Hospital Campus,, Long Lane, Heytesbury Street, Arnott Street & William Place, Dublin 8
- Commenced48 Hamilton Street, Dublin 8, D08 XV48
- Granted15 Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 A3F9
- Commenced8, Susan Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 E0YK
- Commenced7 O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8, D08 R8Y7
- Withdrawn35 Darley's Terrace, St Catherines, Dublin 8
- Granted5 Ebenezer Terrace, D08 X0X4
- Commenced47, Lombard Street West, Dublin 8, D08 H0V2
- Withdrawn47, Lombard Street West, Dublin 8
- Granted2, Malpas Place, The Liberties. Dublin 8, D08 T1K7
- Withdrawn2, Malpas Place, Dublin 8
- Refused28, Daniel Street, Dublin 8, D08 X7DD
- Commenced121 South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 YNX7
- Granted2 Greenville Parade, Dublin 8, D08 E1C2
- Withdrawn28, Daniel Street, Dublin 8, D08 X7DD
- CommencedNo. 10 Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 N8F2
- CommencedThe Brickworks, Brickfield Lane, Dublin 8. The site is located to the west of Brickfield Lane and, north of Brown Street South
- CommencedBlock 500/600 Cathedral Court, New Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn28, Daniel Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn2, Greenville Parade, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Headline Bar , Junction of 57 Clanbrassil Street Lower & South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08HC79
- Granted33 Long Lane, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 P3C3
- Commenced13, St. John's Street, Dublin, D08 X8K1
- Commenced1, Petrie Road, Dublin 8
- Commenced71, Clarence Mangan Road, The Tenters, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn1, Petrie Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn71, Clarence Mangan Road, The Tenters, Dublin 8, D08HE3
- Withdrawn2 Greenville Parade, Dublin 8
- Commenced14, Gilbert Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn14, Gilbert Road, Dublin 8
- Granted113, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided1A Clanbrassil Street Lower, Dublin 8, D08 YK26
- Refused13, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8
- Commenced118, South Circular Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- GrantedApt. 1, 4 Ardee Street, Dublin 8, D08PA61
- Commenced44 Dufferin Avenue, St. Catherine's, Dublin 8, D08 E1C7
- Granted7, Brown Street South, St. Catherine's, Dublin 8 D08 T6X4
- Withdrawn118, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 VHW0
- GrantedOn the public footpath on the southern side of Cork Street, outside "The Loom" and opposite 113 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced24 Saint John's Street, Dublin 8, D08 E1W9
- Commenced12, Blackpitts, Dublin 8, D08 AN27
- Commenced32, Brown Street South, The Tenters,Dublin 8 D08 X8A0
- Withdrawn24, St John's Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced13 Eugene Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced5, Emorville Avenue, Dublin 8
- Commenced13, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 YC9V
- Granted10, O'Curry Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 W1X0
- Commenced14, Merton Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 W5K6
- Granted59 Harty Place, Dublin 8
- Commenced23, St. John's Street, Dublin 8, D08V8NK
- Commenced5, O'Donovan Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 W2A4
- Granted7, Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 N2F3
- Refused5, Ardee Street, Dublin 08
- Granted98-100 South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 V5YA
- Withdrawn5, O'Donovan Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 W2A4
- CommencedNewmarket Square, Dublin 8, P08 P3Y2. The overall site is bound by St. Luke's Avenue, Newmarket Square, Brabazon Street & Newmarket
- Withdrawn5, O'Donovan Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 W2A4
- Withdrawn5 Ardee Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided69D, Donore Avenue, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn32, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 Y7W8
- Withdrawn32, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 Y7W8
- Withdrawn13, Eugene Street, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnSite bound by Newmarket Square to the north, Ardee Street to the west and Mill Street to the south (including City House and Unit 3, Newmarket, Dublin 8), Newmarket, Dublin 8
- GrantedSite Bounded by Wesley Place, and Rear of 11-13 Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnSite bounded by Wesley Place and rear of 11-13 Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8
- Commenced54 John Street South, The Liberties, Dublin 8, D08 N7CO
- GrantedOn the footpath on the southern side of Cork Street outside The Loom and opposite 113 Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedSite at New Street, off New Street South, Dublin 8
- CommencedNos. 9, 10, Ardee Street corner St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8, D08KP9P
- GrantedScoil Treasa Naofa, Petrie Road, Donore Avenue, Dublin 8
- Granted10, Gilbert Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- GrantedUnit 3, Southgate, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Granted6, Weaver's Square, Dublin 8 D08 RHH4
- Appeal decided21, Daniel Street, Dublin 8 D08 X6Y7
- Withdrawn6, Weaver's Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn21, Daniel Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn21, Daniel Street, Dublin 8 D08 X6Y7
- Granted33, Mill Street, Liberties, Dublin 8
- Commenced16, John Street South, Dublin 8 D08 F2V5
- Commenced22, Lombard Street West, Portobello, Dublin 8
- CommencedPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount , Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- Granted7, Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8
- Commenced27-29, New Row South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn16, John Street South, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn33, Mill Street, Liberties, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn7, Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 N2F3
- Commenced48, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 R2T9
- WithdrawnPresentation Secondary School, Warrenmount, Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8
- Commenced39, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 N2V4
- Granted23, Greenville Avenue, Saint Catherine's, Dublin 8, D08 N9E2
- Withdrawn39, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 N2V4
- Withdrawn23, Greenville Avenue, Saint Catherine's, Dublin 8 D08 N9E2
- Refused32 & 33, Lower Clanbrassil Street, Dublin 8
- RefusedLongwood Lane to the rear of No. 103 South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn32 & 33, Lower Clanbrassil Street, Dublin 8
- GrantedAparto the Loom, Cork Street, The Liberties, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnLongwood Lane, Rear 103 South Circular Road, Dublin 8
- Commenced9, Donore Terrace, South Brown Street, Dublin 8, D08Y3C2
- Commenced13-17, Newmarket Square, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn9 Donore Terrace, South Brown Street, Dublin 8, D08Y3C2
- WithdrawnAparto The Loom, Cork Street, the Liberties, Dublin 8
- GrantedSite of 0.115 hectares located at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8 (lands comprising part of the site known as the IDA Ireland Small Business Centre at Newmarket Industrial Estate and Brabazon Place and including pa
- WithdrawnSite at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8 (lands comprising part of the site known as the IDA Ireland Small Business Centre at Newmarket Industrial Estate and including parts of 10, 12, 13 and 14 Newmarket Industrial)
- CommencedSite known as The Brewery Block bounded, By, Ardee Street, Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row, Saint Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8
- GrantedLittle Bird Cafe, 82, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 FC62
- Withdrawn11A O'Carolan Road, Dublin 8, D08 A2T9
- Commenced55, Clarence Mangan Road, Dublin 8, D08 RXE8
- CommencedSweeney's Terrace, Dublin 8, including No.4 Sweeney's Terrace (a habitable house to the rear of No. 1 Sweeney's Terrace)., The site is generally bound by a Student Accommodation and Residential Scheme permitted under An, Bord Pleanala Ref. ABP-303436-19
- WithdrawnSite at Newmarket, Brabazon Place, Brabazon Row and St. Luke's Avenue, Dublin 8
- Commenced26, Hamilton Street, Dublin 8, D08 W2V6
- Commenced18, Rutledge Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 PY2T
- Commenced27 Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 WP9A
- Withdrawn18, Rutledge Terrace, Dublin 8 D08 PY2T
- Other26, Hamilton Street, Dublin 8, D08 W2V6
- Granted18, John Street South, Dublin 8, D08 VXR9.
- Commenced13, Susan Terrace, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 RVW8
- Commenced36, Hamilton Street, Dublin 8
- Granted37, Sandford Avenue, Dublin 8
- Appeal decided37, Oscar Square, Saint Catherine's Dublin 8
- Withdrawn37, Sandford Avenue, Dublin 8 D08 P9Y1
- Withdrawn27, Ebenezer Terrace, Dublin 8, D08 WP9A
- Granted35, Darleys Terrace, St Catherines, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn13, Susan Terrace, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 RVW8
- Withdrawn13, Susan Terrace, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 D08 RVW8
- Withdrawn35, Darleys Terrace, St. Catherines, Dublin 8
- Appeal decidedNo. 8 Newmarket and No. 18 Mill Street, Dublin 8
- CommencedThe Loom, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Withdrawn18, John Street South Dublin, D08 VXR9
- Granted62, Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8
- Appealed64, Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8, D08 A394
- Commenced13, Williams Place South, Portobello, Dublin 8 , D08V2X8
- Granted19, Dufferin Avenue, Dublin 8, D08 Y1X5
- Withdrawn8, Newmarket, and 18, Mill Street, Dublin 8 (bounded by Mill Street to the south, Mill Lane to the east and Newmarket to the north).
- Appeal decidedRear of 13 Emorville Avenue, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 R22W
- Withdrawn62 Clanbrassil Street Upper, Dublin 8
- Commenced1 Coolevin Road, Long Lane, Dublin 8
- WithdrawnRear of 13 Emorville Avenue, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08R22W
- WithdrawnGround Floor Retail Unit, The Loom, Cork Street, Dublin 8
- Commenced6, Oakfield Place, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 K2C5
- Granted10, Coolevin Road, Portobello, Dublin 8, D08 DKX5
- Granted5, Greenville Terrace, Dublin 8, D08TP6W
- WithdrawnNo. 1 Coolevin Road, Long Lane, Dublin 8.
Homes nearby
- For sale42 Hammond Street, South Dublin City, Dublin 8, D08 CDY2
- For sale23 Saint Michaels Terrace, Blackpitts, Dublin 8, D08 R8Y9
- For sale5 O'Carolan Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 F7X2
- For sale16 Saint John'S Street, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 H2V9
- For sale4 Madden Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 X3WF
- For sale39 Dufferin Avenue, South Circular Road, Dublin 8, D08 K2F4
Development land nearby
- Permitted, not started · 33 homes granted 16 Mar 2023, expires 16 Mar 2028 — 10-12 Newmarket and 32 Mill Street (0.3 km)
- Permitted, not started · 49 homes granted 02 Jun 2026, expires 02 Jun 2031 — 28-34 Braithwaite Street and 63-66 Pimlico (0.5 km)
- Permitted, not started · 11 homes granted 01 Dec 2025, expires 01 Dec 2030 — 67-70 Meath Street (0.6 km)
- Residential land off St Thomas Road, Dublin 8 (0.0 km)
- Residential land off St Thomas Road, South Circular Road, Dublin 8 (0.0 km)
Appeal
ACP 320026 · Leave to Appeal S37(6) · decided · Invalid 27 Jun 2024
Building started
- 12 Aug 2024 · Builder told the council work was starting (opted out of the finish sign-off) CN0118322DC
Zoning
Zone Z2 - DEV PLAN 2022-2028
R2 — Existing residential
An established residential area. The objective is to protect existing residential amenity as well as to provide housing — which is the objective a neighbour's objection to an overbearing extension is usually argued under.
Protections nearby 250 m
Flood area nearby (OPW maps). floodinfo.ie ↗
- NIAH-recorded building · 6
- Recorded monument · 9
Where this comes from
National planning feed (NPAD), fetched 11 Sept 2026, 18:51.
Source: National Planning Application Database · fetched 11 Sept 2026, 18:51
| Source | Licence | Fetched | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| National Planning Application Database | CC BY 4.0 | 11 Sept 2026, 18:51 | open |
Summary
WEB1439/24 is a planning application to Dublin City Council for the development will consist of conversion of existing roof/attic storage space to, received on 15 Apr 2024; permission was granted on 7 Jun 2024.